Penumbral imaging and functional outcome in patients with anterior circulation ischaemic stroke treated with endovascular thrombectomy versus medical therapy: a meta-analysis of individual patient-level data
Bruce Campbell
(1)
,
Charles Majoie
(2)
,
Gregory Albers
(3)
,
Bijoy Menon
(4)
,
Nawaf Yassi
(1, 5)
,
M Sharma
(1)
,
Wim van Zwam
(6)
,
Robert van Oostenbrugge
(6)
,
Andrew Demchuk
(4)
,
Francis Guillemin
(7)
,
Philip White
(8)
,
Antoni Dávalos
(9)
,
Aad van Der Lugt
(10)
,
Kenneth Butcher
(11)
,
Aboubaker Cherifi
(12)
,
Henk Marquering
(2)
,
Geoffrey Cloud
(13)
,
Juan Macho Fernández
,
Jeremy Madigan
(14)
,
Catherine Oppenheim
(15)
,
Geoffrey Donnan
(5)
,
Yvo Roos
(2)
,
Jai Shankar
(16)
,
Hester Lingsma
(10)
,
Alain Bonafé
(17)
,
Hélène Raoult
(18)
,
María Hernández-Pérez
(9)
,
Aditya Bharatha
(19)
,
Reza Jahan
(20)
,
Olav Jansen
(21)
,
Sébastien Richard
(22, 23, 24)
,
Elad Levy
(25)
,
Olvert Berkhemer
(2, 6, 10)
,
Marc Soudant
(7)
,
Lucia Aja
,
Stephen Davis
(1)
,
Timo Krings
(26)
,
Marie Tisserand
(27)
,
Luis San Román
(13)
,
Alejandro Tomasello
(28)
,
Debbie Beumer
(6)
,
Scott Brown
,
David Liebeskind
(20)
,
Serge Bracard
(29, 30)
,
Keith Muir
(31, 32)
,
Diederik Dippel
(10)
,
Mayank Goyal
(4)
,
Jeffrey Saver
(33)
,
Tudor Jovin
,
Michael Hill
(4)
,
Peter Mitchell
(1)
,
Puck Ss Fransen
,
Lucie van den Berg
,
Albert Yoo
,
Wouter Schonewille
,
Jan Albert Vos
,
Paul Nederkoorn
,
Marieke Jh Wermer
,
Marianne Aa van Walderveen
,
Julie Staals
,
Jeannette Hofmeijer
,
Jacques van Oostayen
,
Geert Lycklama À Nijeholt
,
Jelis Boiten
,
Patrick Brouwer
,
Bart Emmer
,
Sebastiaan de Bruijn
,
Lukas van Dijk
,
Jaap Kappelle
,
Rob Lo
,
Ewoud van Dijk
,
Joost de Vries
,
Paul L.M. de Kort
,
Willem Jan J. van Rooij
,
Jan S.P. van den Berg
,
Boudewijn A.A.M. van Hasselt
,
Leo A.M. Aerden
,
René Dallinga
,
Marieke Visser
,
Joseph C.J. Bot
,
Patrick Vroomen
,
Omid Eshghi
,
Tobien H.C.M.L. Schreuder
,
Roel J.J. Heijboer
,
Koos Keizer
,
Alexander Tielbeek
,
Heleen den Hertog
,
Dick Gerrits
,
Renske van den Berg-Vos
,
Giorgos Karas
,
Ewout Steyerberg
,
Zwenneke Flach
,
Marieke E.S. Sprengers
,
Sjoerd F.M. Jenniskens
,
Ludo F.M. Beenen
,
René van den Berg
,
Peter Koudstaal
,
Yvo B.W.E.M. Roos
,
Naziha Ghannouti
,
Charles B.L.M. Majoie
,
Diederik W.J. Dippel
,
Thomas Liebig
,
Theo Stijnen
,
Tommy Andersson
,
Nils Wahlgren
,
Esther van Der Heijden
,
Nadine Fleitour
,
Imke Hooijenga
,
Corina Puppels
,
Wilma Pellikaan
,
Annet Geerling
,
Annemieke Lindl-Velema
,
Gina van Vemde
,
Ans de Ridder
,
Paut Greebe
,
José de Bont-Stikkelbroeck
,
Joke de Meris
,
Kirsten Janssen
,
Willy Struijk
,
Silvan Licher
,
Nikki Boodt
,
Adriaan Ros
,
Esmee Venema
,
Ilse Slokkers
,
Raymie-Jayce Ganpat
,
Maxim Mulder
,
Nawid Saiedie
,
Alis Heshmatollah
,
Stefanie Schipperen
,
Stefan Vinken
,
Tiemen van Boxtel
,
Jeroen Koets
,
Merel Boers
,
Emilie Santos
,
Jordi Borst
,
Ivo Jansen
,
Manon Kappelhof
,
Marit Lucas
,
Ralph Geuskens
,
Renan Sales Barros
,
Roeland Dobbe
,
Marloes Csizmadia
,
Md Hill
,
Am Demchuk
,
Bk Menon
,
Kj Ryckborst
,
Nr Kamal
,
L Andersen
,
Pa Randhawa
,
S Patil
,
M Almekhlafi
,
S Mishra
,
F Clement
,
D Roy
,
Jl Rempel
,
Ay Poppe
,
S Subramaniam
,
G Hull
,
Mw Lowerison
,
T Sajobi
,
Mr Wright
,
M Maxwell
,
S Lacusta
,
E Drupals
,
K Armitage
,
Pa Barber
,
Ee Smith
,
Sb Coutts
,
C Derdeyn
,
B Demaerschalk
,
R Martin
,
R Brant
,
Y Yu
,
C Kenney
,
H Aram
,
Pk Stys
,
Tw Watson
,
G Klein
,
D Pearson
,
P Couillard
,
A Trivedi
,
D Singh
,
E Klourfeld
,
O Imoukhuede
,
D Nikneshan
,
S Blayney
,
R Reddy
,
P Choi
,
M Horton
,
T Musuka
,
V Dubuc
,
Ts Field
,
J Desai
,
S Adatia
,
A Alseraya
,
V Nambiar
,
R van Dijk
,
Jh Wong
,
Ap Mitha
,
Wf Morrish
,
Nj Newcommon
,
A Shuaib
,
B Schwindt
,
Ks Butcher
,
T Jeerakathil
,
B Buck
,
K Khan
,
Ss Naik
,
Dj Emery
,
Rj Owen
,
Tb Kotylak
,
Ra Ashforth
,
Ta Yeo
,
D Mcnally
,
M Siddiqui
,
M Saqqur
,
D Hussain
,
H Kalashyan
,
A Manosalva
,
M Kate
,
L Gioia
,
S Hasan
,
A Mohammad
,
M Muratoglu
,
D Williams
,
J Thornton
,
A Cullen
,
P Brennan
,
A O'Hare
,
S Looby
,
D Hyland
,
S Duff
,
M Mccusker
,
B Hallinan
,
S Lee
,
J Mccormack
,
A Moore
,
M O'Connor
,
C Donegan
,
L Brewer
,
A Martin
,
K O'Rourke
,
S Smyth
,
P Kelly
,
T Lynch
,
P O'Brien
,
A O'Driscoll
,
M Martin
,
T Daly
,
R Collins
,
T Coughlan
,
D Mccabe
,
S Murphy
,
D O'Neill
,
M Mulroy
,
O Lynch
,
T Walsh
,
M O'Donnell
,
T Galvin
,
J Harbison
,
P Mcelwaine
,
K Mulpeter
,
C Mcloughlin
,
M Reardon
,
E Harkin
,
E Dolan
,
M Watts
,
N Cunningham
,
C Fallon
,
S Gallagher
,
P Cotter
,
M Crowe
,
R Doyle
,
I Noone
,
M Lapierre
,
Va Coté
,
S Lanthier
,
C Odier
,
A Durocher
,
J Raymond
,
A Weill
,
N Daneault
,
Y Deschaintre
,
L Massaro
,
C Jackson-Graves
,
S Decesare
,
P Porter
,
K Armbruster
,
A Adams
,
J Billigan
,
A Aghaebrahim
,
M Starr
,
S Streib
,
S Rangaraju
,
Fl Silver
,
L Kalman
,
A Cayley
,
J Williams
,
T Stewart
,
R Wiegner
,
Lk Casaubon
,
C Jaigobin
,
Jm del Campo
,
E Elamin
,
Jd Schaafsma
,
Ra Willinsky
,
R Agid
,
R Farb
,
K ter Brugge
,
Bl Sapkoda
,
A Knox
,
A Porter
,
N Pitiyanuvath
,
J Patterson
,
J Nichols
,
J Calvert
,
C Fanale
,
Df Frei
,
A Bitner
,
A Novak
,
D Huddle
,
R Bellon
,
D Loy
,
J Wagner
,
I Chang
,
E Lampe
,
B Spencer
,
R Pratt
,
R Bartt
,
S Shine
,
G Dooley
,
T Nguyen
,
M Whaley
,
K Mccarthy
,
J Teitelbaum
,
D Tampieri
,
W Poon
,
N Campbell
,
M Cortes
,
D Dowlatshahi
,
C Lum
,
R Shamloul
,
S Robert
,
G Stotts
,
M Shamy
,
N Steffenhagen
,
D Blacquiere
,
M Hogan
,
M Alhazzaa
,
G Basir
,
H Lesiuk
,
D Iancu
,
H Choe
,
Dc Weisman
,
K Jonczak
,
A Blue-Schaller
,
Q Shah
,
L Mackenzie
,
B Klein
,
K Kulandaivel
,
O Kozak
,
Dj Gzesh
,
Lj Harris
,
Js Khoury
,
J Mandzia
,
D Pelz
,
S Crann
,
L Fleming
,
K Hesser
,
B Beauchamp
,
B Amato-Marzialli
,
M Boulton
,
P Lopez- Ojeda
,
S Lownie
,
R Chan
,
R Swartz
,
P Howard
,
D Golob
,
D Gladstone
,
K Boyle
,
M Boulos
,
J Hopyan
,
V Yang
,
L da Costa
,
Ca Holmstedt
,
As Turk
,
R Navarro
,
E Jauch
,
S Ozark
,
R Turner
,
S Phillips
,
J Jarrett
,
G Gubitz
,
W Maloney
,
R Vandorpe
,
M Schmidt
,
J Heidenreich
,
G Hunter
,
M Kelly
,
R Whelan
,
L Peeling
,
Pa Burns
,
A Hunter
,
I Wiggam
,
E Kerr
,
M Watt
,
A Fulton
,
P Gordon
,
I Rennie
,
P Flynn
,
G Smyth
,
S O'Leary
,
N Gentile
,
G Linares
,
P Mcnelis
,
K Erkmen
,
P Katz
,
A Azizi
,
M Weaver
,
C Jungreis
,
S Faro
,
P Shah
,
H Reimer
,
V Kalugdan
,
G Saposnik
,
Y Li
,
P Kostyrko
,
M Santos
,
T Marotta
,
Wj Montanera
,
D Sarma
,
D Selchen
,
J Spears
,
Jh Heo
,
K Jeong
,
Dj Kim
,
Bm Kim
,
Yd Kim
,
D Song
,
K-J Lee
,
J Yoo
,
Oy Bang
,
S Rho
,
J Lee
,
P Jeon
,
Kh Kim
,
J Cha
,
Sj Kim
,
S Ryoo
,
Mj Lee
,
S-I Sohn
,
C-H Kim
,
H-G Ryu
,
J-H Hong
,
H-W Chang
,
C-y Lee
,
J Rha
,
Bruce Cv Campbell
,
Leonid Churilov
,
Bernard Yan
,
Richard Dowling
,
Thomas Oxley
,
Teddy Wu
,
Gabriel Silver
,
Amy Mcdonald
,
Rachael Mccoy
,
Timothy Kleinig
,
Rebecca Scroop
,
Helen Dewey
,
Marion Simpson
,
Mark Brooks
,
Bronwyn Coulton
,
Martin Krause
,
Timothy Harrington
,
Brendan Steinfort
,
Kenneth Faulder
,
Miriam Priglinger
,
Susan Day
,
Thanh Phan
,
Winston Chong
,
Michael Holt
,
Ronil Chandra
,
Henry Ma
,
Dennis Young
,
Kitty Wong
,
Tissa Wijeratne
,
Hans Tu
,
Elizabeth Mackay
,
Sherisse Celestino
,
Christopher Bladin
,
Poh Sien Loh
,
Amanda Gilligan
,
Zofia Ross
,
Skye Coote
,
Tanya Frost
,
Mark Parsons
,
Ferdinand Miteff
,
Christopher Levi
,
Timothy Ang
,
Neil Spratt
,
Lara Kaauwai
,
Monica Badve
,
Henry Rice
,
Laetitia de Villiers
,
P. Alan Barber
,
Ben Mcguinness
,
Ayton Hope
,
Maurice Moriarty
,
Patricia Bennett
,
Andrew Wong
,
Alan Coulthard
,
Andrew Lee
,
Jim Jannes
,
Deborah Field
,
Gagan Sharma
,
Simon Salinas
,
Elise Cowley
,
Barry Snow
,
John Kolbe
,
Richard Stark
,
John King
,
Richard Macdonnell
,
John Attia
,
Cate d'Este
,
Hans-Christoph Diener
,
Vitor Mendes Pereira
,
Christophe Cognard
,
David Cohen
,
Werner Hacke
,
Heinrich Mattle
,
Raul Nogueira
,
Dileep Yavagal
,
Rüdiger von Kummer
,
Wade Smith
,
Scott Hamilton
,
Richard Chiacchierini
,
Arun Amar
,
Nerses Sanossian
,
Yince Loh
,
T Devlin
,
Bw Baxter
,
H Hawk
,
B Sapkota
,
S Quarfordt
,
A Sirelkhatim
,
C Dellinger
,
K Barton
,
Vk Reddy
,
A Ducruet
,
A Jadhav
,
A Horev
,
D-V Giurgiutiu
,
V Totoraitis
,
M Hammer
,
L Wechsler
,
M Rocha
,
D Gulati
,
D Campbell
,
M Star
,
L Baxendell
,
J Oakley
,
Adnan Siddiqui
,
Ln Hopkins
,
K Snyder
,
R Sawyer
,
S Hall
,
E Omer
,
M Charif
,
X Ayrignac
,
N Menjot de Champfleur
,
N Leboucq
,
G Gascou
,
M Moynier
,
R Du Mesnil de Rochemont
,
O Singer
,
J Berkefeld
,
C Foerch
,
M Lorenz
,
W Pfeilschifer
,
E Hattingen
,
M Wagner
,
Sj You
,
S Lescher
,
H Braun
,
S Dehkharghani
,
Sr Belagaje
,
A Anderson
,
A Lima
,
M Obideen
,
R Dharia
,
M Frankel
,
V Patel
,
K Owada
,
A Saad
,
L Amerson
,
C Horn
,
S Doppelheuer
,
K Schindler
,
Dk Lopes
,
M Chen
,
R Moftakhar
,
C Anton
,
M Smreczak
,
Js Carpenter
,
S Boo
,
A Rai
,
T Roberts
,
A Tarabishy
,
L Gutmann
,
C Brooks
,
J Brick
,
J Domico
,
G Reimann
,
K Hinrichs
,
M Becker
,
E Heiss
,
C Selle
,
A Witteler
,
S Al-Boutros
,
M-J Danch
,
A Ranft
,
S Rohde
,
K Burg
,
C Weimar
,
V Zegarac
,
C Hartmann
,
M Schlamann
,
S Göricke
,
A Ringlestein
,
I Wanke
,
C Mönninghoff
,
M Dietzold
,
R Budzik
,
T Davis
,
G Eubank
,
Wj Hicks
,
P Pema
,
N Vora
,
J Mejilla
,
M Taylor
,
W Clark
,
J Fields
,
B Peterson
,
G Nesbit
,
H Lutsep
,
H Bozorgchami
,
R Priest
,
O Ologuntoye
,
S Barnwell
,
A Dogan
,
K Herrick
,
C Takahasi
,
N Beadell
,
B Brown
,
S Jamieson
,
Ms Hussain
,
A Russman
,
F Hui
,
D Wisco
,
K Uchino
,
Z Khawaja
,
I Katzan
,
G Toth
,
E Cheng-Ching
,
M Bain
,
S Man
,
A Farrag
,
P George
,
S John
,
L Shankar
,
A Drofa
,
R Dahlgren
,
A Bauer
,
A Itreat
,
A Taqui
,
R Cerejo
,
A Richmond
,
P Ringleb
,
M Bendszus
,
M Möhlenbruch
,
T Reiff
,
H Amiri
,
J Purrucker
,
C Herweh
,
M Pham
,
O Menn
,
I Ludwig
,
I Acosta
,
C Villar
,
W Morgan
,
C Sombutmai
,
F Hellinger
,
E Allen
,
M Bellew
,
R Gandhi
,
E Bonwit
,
J Aly
,
Rd Ecker
,
D Seder
,
J Morris
,
M Skaletsky
,
J Belden
,
C Baker
,
Ls Connolly
,
P Papanagiotou
,
C Roth
,
A Kastrup
,
M Politi
,
F Brunner
,
M Alexandrou
,
H Merdivan
,
C Ramsey
,
C Given Ii
,
S Renfrow
,
V Deshmukh
,
K Sasadeusz
,
F Vincent
,
Jt Thiesing
,
J Putnam
,
A Bhatt
,
A Kansara
,
D Caceves
,
T Lowenkopf
,
L Yanase
,
J Zurasky
,
S Dancer
,
B Freeman
,
T Scheibe-Mirek
,
J Robison
,
A Rontal
,
J Roll
,
D Clark
,
M Rodriguez
,
B-Fm Fitzsimmons
,
O Zaidat
,
Jr Lynch
,
M Lazzaro
,
T Larson
,
L Padmore
,
E Das
,
A Farrow-Schmidt
,
A Hassan
,
W Tekle
,
C Cate
,
C Cnyrim
,
F Wodarg
,
C Wiese
,
A Binder
,
C Riedel
,
A Rohr
,
N Lang
,
H Laufs
,
S Krieter
,
L Remonda
,
M Diepers
,
J Añon
,
K Nedeltchev
,
T Kahles
,
S Biethahn
,
M Lindner
,
V Chang
,
C Gächter
,
C Esperon
,
M Guglielmetti
,
Jf Arenillas Lara
,
M Martínez Galdámez
,
Ai Calleja Sanz
,
E Cortijo Garcia
,
S Perez
,
P Mulero Carrillo
,
E Crespo Vallejo
,
M Ruiz Piñero
,
L Lopez Mesonero
,
Fj Reyes Muñoz
,
C Brekenfeld
,
J-H Buhk
,
A Krützelmann
,
G Thomalla
,
B Cheng
,
C Beck
,
J Hoppe
,
E Goebell
,
B Holst
,
U Grzyska
,
G Wortmann
,
S Starkman
,
G Duckwiler
,
N Rao
,
S Sheth
,
K Ng
,
A Noorian
,
V Szeder
,
M Nour
,
M Mcmanus
,
J Huang
,
J Tarpley
,
S Tateshima
,
N Gonzalez
,
L Ali
,
J Hinman
,
M Calderon-Arnulphi
,
C Liang
,
J Guzy
,
S Koch
,
K Desousa
,
G Gordon-Perue
,
D Haussen
,
M Elhammady
,
E Peterson
,