AI as Philosophical Ideology: A Critical look back at McCarthy’s Program - Department of Natural Language Processing & Knowledge Discovery Accéder directement au contenu
Communication Dans Un Congrès Année : 2023

AI as Philosophical Ideology: A Critical look back at McCarthy’s Program

Marc M Anderson
  • Fonction : Auteur
  • PersonId : 1123682

Résumé

AI has become the poster child for a certain kind of thinking which holds that some technologies can become objective, independent and emergent entities which can evolve beyond the control of their creators. This thinking is not new however. It is a product of certain philosophical ideas such as materialism, a common-sense world of objective and independent objects, a correspondence theory of truth, and so forth, which are centered around the pre-eminence of science, epistemology, and logical reasoning, among others, as the supremely valid modes of engaging experience. This paper aims to critically examine the synthesis of the development program for AI to be found in the writings of computer scientist John McCarthy (1927-2011). McCarthy has been called one of the founding fathers of AI. First, some of the main themes which recur in his writings from as early as the mid nineteen fifties in the Dartmouth proposal, up to his late writings, are considered. A discussion of the goals that such a program implies, follows, in terms of society’s relation with AI based technology and the nature and purpose of AI itself. These implications are arguably related to social control and are also moral. Ultimately, McCarthy’s idea that AI is and can be built upon a paradigm of reasoning and logic so as to simulate a perfectly rational abstraction of human thinking is shown to be motivated by his view that AI systems should be controlled, as servants. This understanding of human thinking is questionable, however, given current research on human irrationality, as well as on the argumentative role of reasoning. And yet, the process of development toward the unachievable goal of controllable, rational, logical AI systems, has handily come to serve as a blind for increasing techno-corporate control of society, with techno-corporate interests displacing blame for devaluations and harms caused by their push to develop the technology to AI systems which they can conveniently ‘lose control of.’
Fichier non déposé

Dates et versions

hal-04364525 , version 1 (27-12-2023)

Licence

Paternité

Identifiants

  • HAL Id : hal-04364525 , version 1

Citer

Marc M Anderson. AI as Philosophical Ideology: A Critical look back at McCarthy’s Program. Philosophy in Technology Workshop 2nd Edition, Wrocław University of Science and Technology; the Pontifical University of John Paul II, and the Polish Academy of Arts and Sciences, Apr 2023, Wrocław, Poland. ⟨hal-04364525⟩
11 Consultations
0 Téléchargements

Partager

Gmail Facebook X LinkedIn More